The main purpose of this blog is to examine the claim that the laws of physics are fine-tuned for life, and even more specifically human life. This is a claim you will find being made in religious apologetic writings and even in seemingly serious books and papers on physics and cosmology. In religious circles the fine tuning is used to derive the existence of a deity. Physicists try to explain why it is so, or use so-called anthropic reasoning to predict certain properties of the Universe. My main contention is that both apologists and physicists make the mistake of not distinguishing between the laws of physics and the reality they are only an approximate description of. The laws of physics are models made up by humans. They are not arbitrary human constructions since we judge their quality by how well they describe observations and experiments, but they are still, unlike the external world, things we have made up. If they appear to be fine-tuned for anything it does not follow that the universe is so, too. And if we want to find the fine-tuner of these laws we only have to look in the mirror.
In my posts I will try to explain my take on fine-tuning in more detail, but also review a selection of the literature on the topic. I hope they will be at least partly understandable and moderately interesting.
Great idea for a blog!
ReplyDelete